YVEA board has 1 contested race

photo

Russ Garrity

photo

Chuck Perry

photo

Scott McGill

— A longtime Oak Creek resident is squaring off against a Toponas incumbent in the only contested race this year for the Yampa Valley Electric Association’s board of directors.

YVEA will begin mailing ballots Thursday for its annual board election. Association members can vote for candidates in one of three districts up for election this year. Jim Chappell, YVEA manager of consumer accounts, said the contested race is between District 9 incumbent Chuck Perry and challenger Russ Garrity.

Garrity, 52, a 20-year Oak Creek resident, earned an engineering degree from the University of Massachusetts in 1982 and has spent 30 years in the power business. He works as director of business development for GP Strategies, an international engineering consulting firm. Garrity said his niche is coal-fired power plants.

His career has taken him from Craig Station to the first coal plants built in Malaysia and Morocco to the soon-to-be-largest coal-fired power plant in the world — the Medupi Station in South Africa.

It’s his international experience that Garrity is leaning on in his campaign for the YVEA board.

“After 30 years in the business, I’m looking to get involved and give back to my community,” Garrity said. “I understand the power business and I think I can help the board make logical, forward-thinking decisions to help keep costs down, supplies up and increase our options for energy supply.”

While Garrity is looking to begin giving back to his community, Perry is looking for the opportunity to continue his service to association customers.

“Our national economy puts a lot of stress on local families, which are struggling to keep kids in school and food on the table,” Perry said. “I want to keep electricity for families as affordable as possible and we’ve been successful in doing that.”

Perry, 62, of Toponas, was first elected to the YVEA board in 2006. He serves as the board’s designated representative to the Colorado Rural Electric Association.

This is his second contested election in three campaigns.

A fifth-generation Routt County rancher, Perry said his platform is based on maintaining YVEA as the lowest residential power supplier among Colorado cooperatives, which contrary to popular opinion, means maintaining a robust coal-fired power generation portfolio.

“The reason I’m running is because there is a national movement to extinguish coal-fired generation and there are chapters all over America trying to take over these rural cooperatives,” Perry said. “Locally, there is an effort to draft candidates with the same philosophical zeal to take over a board that runs against the nature and the spirit in which the cooperative was formed.”

That effort, Perry believes, is spearheaded by a Steamboat Springs group that has an agenda to expand YVEA’s renewable energy portfolio.

“Regardless of what the (federal) government says, the green jobs are not there,” Perry said. “Wind and solar power will not replace coal-fired and nuclear-based generation. They are intermittent power sources and cannot stand alone in a free-market economy.”

Despite Perry’s views on green energy, he said the YVEA board recently renegotiated its supply contract with Xcel Energy to begin adding renewables such as solar gardens to YVEA’s portfolio.

The YVEA board includes nine members representing association districts from State Bridge in Eagle County to Baggs in Carbon County, Wyo. Almost all of Moffat and Routt counties are located within YVEA’s service area.

District board members are elected to three-year terms and elections take place annually on a three-district rotation.

Also up for election this year are the association’s District 1 and District 8 seats.

Peggy Espy, who currently sits on the board in District 1, is not seeking another term, Chappell said, and YVEA did not receive any candidate petitions.

In District 8, Scott McGill is running unopposed in his re-election bid and will be “deemed elected according to the rules and regulations of the association’s bylaws,” Chappell said.

The board will address the District 1 vacancy and announce results of the District 9 election during its annual meeting at 10 a.m. June 16 at the Hayden High School auditorium.

Customers who plan to vote in the election must return their ballots by mail or drop them off at YVEA’s Steamboat Springs office, 32 10th St., by 5 p.m. June 15.

Community comments

Note: The Steamboat Pilot & Today doesn’t necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post. Read our full policy.

(Scott Wedel) Scott_Wedel says...

If Russ Garrity is an Oak Creek resident then he is not being served by YVEA since OC has it's own municipal electric company.

Posted 22 May 2012, 8:12 a.m. Suggest removal

(Russ Garrity) russgarrity says...

Hi Scott:

I actually live right outside the Oak Creek town line on County Road 27. I lived in town for 8 years, and have been outside town for 12 years. But since my PO box has always been in Oak Creek, we call that address our home. I do pay my bill to YVEA so I am able to run for the YVEA Board of Directors. Thanks. Russ

Posted 24 May 2012, 7:30 p.m. Suggest removal

(jerry carlton) jlc says...

Russ I voted for you. Never vote for the incumbent for anything. Need to keep new blood coming in all the time no matter what the office is!

Posted 24 May 2012, 9:43 p.m. Suggest removal

(Scott Wedel) Scott_Wedel says...

Russ,
Thanks. I thought that needed to be explained.

I looked up the map for YVEA board members and I did not see a hole for Oak Creek so as far as I know, an OC resident could run for YVEA's board.

Personally, I wish YVEA could take over OC's electric service. It would be so nice to no longer have scheduled town wide power outages for work on the Town's substation. Nor is it good that when there is an issue that outages are extended until the electrical contractor can arrive from Craig. And it would be so nice to have an electric utility with normal policies which comply to PUC customer regulations regarding deposits, the returning of deposits, the size of late fees and disconnect procedures. And look at the service line from the alley to the old wash house on Main St. Yep, so close to the ground that someone can step over it. But in Oak Creek that is not a safety issue because it has not yet hurt anyone. That is what I was told when I asked about it.

Posted 25 May 2012, 9:37 a.m. Suggest removal

(Scott Wedel) Scott_Wedel says...

Tom,
So now you are a single issue voter using candidate's opinion on Obama to determine how you vote for a seat on the board of the nonpartisan local electric co-op? Wow! Someone is at least slightly obsessive. What else? You want Russ's long form birth certificate?

I guess Russ and Chuck Perry should also describe their personal religious views to allow a particular American Christian to exercise his right as a religious bigot to vote based upon which candidate is sufficiently Christian.

Posted 25 May 2012, 9:46 a.m. Suggest removal

(jerry carlton) jlc says...

Scott Wedel Why did you use the term Christian in your post to Tom? Are you bigoted against Christians? Why did you not use the term Muslim? Would that be politically incorrect? It is OK to bad mouth Christians in your world but not Muslims?

Posted 26 May 2012, 2:20 p.m. Suggest removal

(mark hartless) markhartless says...

JLC,
Muslims can't be religious bigots.

Just like,
Blacks can't be racists.
Women can't be overpaid.
Governments can't be greedy.
Immigrants can't be illegal.
Coal can't be clean... and homosexuals can't be in the wrong bathroom

Posted 26 May 2012, 5:55 p.m. Suggest removal

(Scott Wedel) Scott_Wedel says...

I was referring to a letter to the editor a couple weeks ago by a person calling himself an American Christian who then proceed to judge Romney and Obama based upon their adherence to his views of Christianity.

Posted 26 May 2012, 8:04 p.m. Suggest removal

(jerry carlton) jlc says...

Scott Wedel You replied to one question. What about the other 4? The one I would really like a response to is "Are you bigoted against Christians?"

Mark Amen!

Posted 27 May 2012, 8:50 a.m. Suggest removal

(Russ Garrity) russgarrity says...

Hi all:

I just returned from a week in Florida working at a trash-to-energy plant owned by Waste Management. Sorry I have not been able to follow these comments more closely. My two comments are:

1. I am running for YVEA because I think my experience and qualifiations will help our membership (I have no other agenda). So can we please limit the discussions on this particular YVEA article to that topic ?? Thanks in advance.

2. Tom, I'll be back in the office Tuesday and would be more than happy to talk with you about current Energy Policy any time. Would you be able to call me at 736 - 1020 ??

Thank you all.
Russ

Posted 27 May 2012, 9:33 a.m. Suggest removal

(Russ Garrity) russgarrity says...

Hi Tom:

You raise a good point, and I definitely enjoyed our conversation on the phone today. Thanks for taking the time.....

As I hopefully explained, I have lots of "opinions" on Energy Policy, but no pre-set agenda for YVEA. If I am lucky enough to get elected, I intend to study every aspect of the YVEA operation. I'm a hard worker and will come up to speed quickly. Then I will contribute to the BoD conversations using my expertise on coal, oil, renewable energy, transmission issues, and other topics. I look forward to bringing a new perspective to the BoD.

If anyone else has any questions for me regarding Energy Policy, please call me at 736 - 1020. I'd like to hear from you.

Take care
Russ

Posted 29 May 2012, 2:23 p.m. Suggest removal

Post a comment (Requires free registration)

Posting comments requires a free account and verification.